if i sang out of tune | (glee fanfiction excerpt)
“How have you been since we last talked?”
Quinn looks at her hands. They’re balled into fists in her lap. ”I’m fine,” she says. She forces herself to meet the therapist’s gaze. ”I don’t know what you want me to say. I’m fine.” Her smile is bright. It’s beautiful. She knows it is, knows she looks just like what a happy, pretty girl ought to look like, and she knows, from the way Dr. Baumgarten looks at her, that it is not enough.
*
Here’s the thing: There are words that get trapped inside of Quinn, silences that fall out of her where confessions ought to be. She’s not sure where it started. With Lucy, the self she murdered, the ghost that haunts her. With Puck and too much wine, with Beth, perfect Beth, too perfect for someone like Quinn. It could be before that, with her parents and their ideal of who she should be — or even earlier, maybe, something in the way Quinn was formed, her chromosomes put together wrong, her soul delivered to her stretched-out and torn. That’s how she imagines it. Her soul is a second-hand dress that doesn’t fit. It’s not really hers at all.
Quinn watches herself fall apart — but it doesn’t matter, does it? Quinn, in the long run, is just some second-hand girl who never made one right choice, not once, in her whole stupid life.
*
(more to come)